top of page

The Menopause Two-Year Mindset War: When 'Strong Not Small' Isn't Enough - Ignoring The Scale In Menopause.

  • Writer: Michelle Gerber
    Michelle Gerber
  • Oct 13, 2025
  • 2 min read

Updated: Feb 28

I’m going to be completely honest with you. It’s not so easy to practice what you preach—and this week, I really had to take a step back and face that truth.


If you’re a woman in menopause and grew up in a similar era to me, I know that at some point, you were subjected to the same pervasive pressures I was. I mean, we were. Poor body image thoughts, the tyranny of being 'tiny and small,' and a constant struggle with "not being thin enough" shaped our formative years.


I truly believed I had conquered that mindset. My mantra is clear: Be strong, not small. Build muscle. Recompose your body. Ignore the scale.

But this week, it hit me hard.


I was training as hard as ever—following my plan for longevity with high-protein meals, strength work, and cardio. I've seen incredible gains over the last two years.


Yet, despite knowing the science and preaching the benefits, the moment I stepped on the scale, everything fell apart.


The number was up. That voice from years ago, whispering, "It’s all about the number," was deafening.


Ignoring the scale in menopause
Be strong, not small. Build muscle. Recompose your body. Ignore the scale.

My rational brain screamed the truth: You have built muscle and lost significant fat; weight gain is a sign of success! But I found myself questioning everything and immediately wanting to go on a diet. That is the ingrained struggle we face.


The vow I’ve made with myself going forward is this: No more weighing. I am going to ignore the scale on my menopause journey. I will continue to focus objectively on my body composition and celebrate the amazing gains I have truly made.

This is the real work of longevity. It’s not just lifting the weight; it’s finally dismantling the decades of self-criticism. If you’re reading this, you are not alone in that silent, frustrating moment where what you know is true battles what you feel is true.



Comments


protein pixie menopause nutrition

PROTEIN PIXIE

The information presented on this website is based on my own personal journey through menopause. It is in no way meant to replace advice from a medical professional. Always consult with a qualified healthcare professional before starting any new diet, exercise program, or health regimen, or if you have any concerns or questions about a medical condition. 

© 2025 by Protein Pixie

bottom of page